Difference between revisions of "Talk:Achievement"

From SoundInGames.com - Sound Design in Games
Jump to: navigation, search
(Created page with "'''Achievement vs. Success''' When refering to the card sometimes users say Success instead of Achievement, mostly when referring to Failure in the same sentence. It seems that S...")
 
m (Achievement vs. Success)
 
(7 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Achievement vs. Success'''
+
== Achievement vs. Success ==
When refering to the card sometimes users say Success instead of Achievement, mostly when referring to Failure in the same sentence. It seems that Success would be more catchy because it is the common opposite of Fauilure. Yet, "success" seems to point towards a more definitive sense of achievement, as when a level is finished. It is not so proper to refer to each small positive reinforcement such as picking coins in Super Mario or rings in Sonic.
+
 
So we still believe Achievement is a better name.
+
When refering to this card in a same context where Failure is also being referred, people sometimes say 'Success' instead of 'Achievement'. In such context it seems that 'Success' would feel more natural because it is the common opposite of 'Failure'. Yet:
Nevertheless, for the sake of usability, we are including a page called Success that redirects to Achievement. That does not have parallel in terms of the cards, naturally.
+
* The term 'success' points towards a more definitive perception of achievement, as when a game level is finished. It is not so interesting to refer to each small positive reinforcement such as picking coins in Super Mario or rings in Sonic.  
[[Special:Contributions/0:0:0:0:0:0:0:1|0:0:0:0:0:0:0:1]] 13:12, 1 July 2011 (WEST)
+
* There is no reason for the patterns Achievement and Failure to be seen as opposite, although they may act close to that in many games. 
 +
So, we still believe 'Achievement' is a better name. Nevertheless, for the sake of usability, here in the site we are including a page called Success that redirects to Achievement.<br />[[User:ValterAlves|ValterAlves]] [pre-release]

Latest revision as of 19:19, 30 December 2011

Achievement vs. Success

When refering to this card in a same context where Failure is also being referred, people sometimes say 'Success' instead of 'Achievement'. In such context it seems that 'Success' would feel more natural because it is the common opposite of 'Failure'. Yet:

  • The term 'success' points towards a more definitive perception of achievement, as when a game level is finished. It is not so interesting to refer to each small positive reinforcement such as picking coins in Super Mario or rings in Sonic.
  • There is no reason for the patterns Achievement and Failure to be seen as opposite, although they may act close to that in many games.

So, we still believe 'Achievement' is a better name. Nevertheless, for the sake of usability, here in the site we are including a page called Success that redirects to Achievement.
ValterAlves [pre-release]